In summary, Dolby Cinema and IMAX are today's most standard formats for enhanced cinema technologies. While both offer great value, IMAX is better for sound and visuals, and Dolby Cinema has better audio with its advanced audio tech. Dolby Cinema is less accessible than the two, whereas IMAX is easily available in most theatres worldwide. Tickets for Dolby Cinema are pricier.
By the way, if you're looking to build a home theatre system, I may have something that might come handy for you.
I've just partnered with an Acoustics and Audio PhD from University of Salford to build a speaker placement calculator. Here's the link to the calculator. I'd definitely recommend you to give it a shot. It's a very simple, online, 2D simulator.
Now let’s go have a closer look at both Dolby and IMAX.
Dolby Cinema's projection technology gives up to four times higher resolution and 500 times higher contrast ratio resulting in a superior screen projection on both standard and digital formats. This definitely gives it a distinct edge. There is no other format offering you a more detailed quality of vision.
That being said, IMAX does give it a run for its money with its proprietary dual laser projection technology. The flip side, though, is that most theatres using IMAX will likely have no dual 4k Laser projections needed to utilize this to its fullest potential, which still offers lesser resolution than the Dolby Cinema.
This is where IMAX ups its game over Dolby Cinema. IMAX technology displays movies with an aspect ratio of 1.90:1. This is approximately 26% more than other movie formats like ETX, AMC Prime, and Dolby Cinema. So with the taller screen and increased detail, the viewer gets a more immersive experience.
Note: Both IMAX and Dolby Cinema come in a quite few formats. So while Dolby Cinema's resolution is higher by 4x compared to standard resolution, IMAX comes with the Digital IMAX, which offers IMAX 3D in addition to its general high resolution, contrast, and brightness. So from a micro perspective, it looks like IMAX might be the winner in this specific department.
Dolby Cinema clearly is at an advantage here. Their Atmos technology is impressive enough on its own. But with theatres including Dolby Cinema AMC transducers onto their seats, what you get is a shockingly realistic and life-like experience where the ground rumbles underneath you and moving objects feel like they're actually in the room.
While IMAX struggles to keep up, don't let us make you think its audio game is shabby. Equipped with speakers that usually come in bigger sizes in most theatres, it gives you lots of power and clarity in its audio delivery, as well. But the immersiveness of the experience is not quite as life-like.
While visual and audio quality is essential points, neither count for much without comfort being included in the entire equation. No technology, no matter how advanced, will give you an enjoyable movie experience without comfortable seats to watch them in.
Dolby Cinema seems to have taken this into careful consideration. Their high-end, adjustable leather seats give you a plush feeling of high-end quality and let you recline to an angle of your preference. And as mentioned before, audio-transducers under these seats add to the enjoyment by letting you feel the sound and not just hear it.
IMAX seats, on the other hand, while not uncomfortable, don't recline and are less spacious too. So it can tend to get a little stiff and crammed on prolonged use, especially for larger body types. And they definitely don’t add to the overall aural experience in any way. So it looks like Dolby Cinema wins again here.
Accessibility to these formats reveals a very interesting dynamic. While Dolby Cinema appears to offer a more tech-savvy, high-end experience theatres offering it as an option are still the minority (197 Dolby Cinemas worldwide with 127 in the US). On the other hand, IMAX is all over the world, with more than 1,500 theatres in 80 countries.
2D vs 3D
Simply put, Dolby Cinemas only offer 2D films. IMAX is the only option for 3D.
Note: Do watch out for fake IMAX theatres, some of whom tend just to use the branding to offer minimally enhanced versions of a standard digital movie as opposed to a genuine, full-blown 3D version.
IMAX offers adult movie tickets for about an average of $20, so that’s just $5 more than the regular tickets for a considerably enhanced experience.
Dolby Cinema tickets will usually range between $20-$25. So they are slightly pricier. You might have to skip the popcorn!
In conclusion, this is how Dolby Cinema and Imax stack up against each other:
- Image Quality: Dolby Cinema wins
- Image Format: IMAX wins.
- Audio: Dolby Cinema wins
- Comfort: Dolby Cinema wins.
- Availability: IMAX wins
- Cost: IMAX wins
While Dolby Cinema is clearly the more high-end cinema experience between the two from a micro perspective. In reality, IMAX’s accessibility and overall high quality makes it a more popular and easier choice between the two.